# academic-paper-review

Use this skill when the user requests to review, analyze, critique, or summarize academic papers, research articles, preprints, or scientific publications. Supports comprehensive structured reviews covering methodology assessment, contribution evaluation, literature positioning, and constructive feedback generation. Trigger on queries involving paper URLs,...

## Decision Card

- Recommendation score: 25/100 (Review first)
- Fit score: 34/100
- Trust tier: Needs review
- Install readiness: Source guide
- Trial status: not_recorded
- Claim status: Unclaimed
- Verified level: Unverified
- Primary risk: No community evaluation
- Next action: manual_review

## Fit & Capabilities

- Role: Coding & Development
- Protocols: manual review
- Capabilities: RAG, Reusable skill package, Coding assistance

## Evidence

- Source: https://www.remoteopenclaw.com/skills/bytedance/deer-flow/academic-paper-review
- Source activity: Source review needed
- Community reviews: 0
- External reputation signals: 0
- Known gaps: community review, third-party review/discussion signal, sandbox trial result

## Risk & Safety

- Security verdict: Evidence is thin. Read source, license, and requirements before trial.
- Required checks: Verify install source, Confirm license, Review permissions, Collect user evaluation

## Installation

- Readiness: Source guide
- Primary method: Source guide
- Install JSON: https://agentstaffer.com/skills/remoteopenclaw-academic-paper-review/install.json

## Trial Plan

- Task: Run a small code review trial
- Expected output: A concise review with reproducible findings, changed-file scope, and test suggestions.
- Trial JSON: https://agentstaffer.com/skills/remoteopenclaw-academic-paper-review/trial.json

## Profile Data Package

- profile.json: https://agentstaffer.com/skills/remoteopenclaw-academic-paper-review/profile.json
- score.json: https://agentstaffer.com/skills/remoteopenclaw-academic-paper-review/score.json
- evidence.json: https://agentstaffer.com/skills/remoteopenclaw-academic-paper-review/evidence.json
- trust.json: https://agentstaffer.com/skills/remoteopenclaw-academic-paper-review/trust.json
- trial.json: https://agentstaffer.com/skills/remoteopenclaw-academic-paper-review/trial.json
- install.json: https://agentstaffer.com/skills/remoteopenclaw-academic-paper-review/install.json
- history.json: https://agentstaffer.com/skills/remoteopenclaw-academic-paper-review/history.json
- similar.json: https://agentstaffer.com/skills/remoteopenclaw-academic-paper-review/similar.json
- dossier.md: https://agentstaffer.com/skills/remoteopenclaw-academic-paper-review/dossier.md
- summary.md: https://agentstaffer.com/skills/remoteopenclaw-academic-paper-review/summary.md
- visibility-report.json: https://agentstaffer.com/vendors/remoteopenclaw-academic-paper-review/visibility-report.json
- claim.json: https://agentstaffer.com/claim.json
- Vendor visibility report: https://agentstaffer.com/vendors/remoteopenclaw-academic-paper-review/visibility-report
- Agent index: https://agentstaffer.com/agents.json